The unveiling of the Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Bill 2024 marks a pivotal moment in the discussion about children’s safety online. UNICEF Australia and essential partners express serious concerns about privacy risks, children’s rights, and the operational impacts of the proposed legislative measures. The critiques emphasise the need for comprehensive, privacy-aware solutions that align online safety with children’s rights to access, participation, and well-being.
UNICEF Australia underscored the risks of “pushing children into covert and unregulated online spaces” due to recent legislation. This shift could result in a loss of essential online resources and support networks for children. UNICEF highlights that, “Children rely on digital platforms for learning, social connection, and mental health support. Measures that arbitrarily restrict access risk exacerbating isolation and denying critical rights under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC).”
Mitigating privacy risks
- Increased data collection and breach vulnerability
The proposed age-verification standards require the collection of sensitive personal information, such as identification documents or biometric data. This significantly raises the chances of data breaches, misuse, and exploitation. UNICEF Australia warns that “Children’s data is heavily traded in digital ecosystems, and the measures under this bill could exacerbate their exposure to privacy violations.”
- Efficacy of enforcement
Recent findings show that children adeptly circumvent age restrictions in online safety initiatives. The eSafety Commissioner acknowledges that these initiatives, while well-intentioned, may unintentionally push children to explore more hidden and unregulated online spaces. This situation heightens their vulnerability, exposing them to harmful content without the protections that established platforms provide.
- Privacy vs. accessibility trade-offs
Age verification systems that apply to the entire population significantly clash with children’s rights to privacy and fair access to online resources. UNICEF stated that “mandatory age-assurance processes could deny children access to vital information and networks essential for their development and wellbeing, particularly in rural or underserved communities.”
- Lack of platform accountability
Limiting children’s access to social media may unintentionally free platforms from their responsibility to create secure and suitable environments for young users. The Joint Select Committee on Social Media and the Australian Society stated, “evicting children from these spaces removes the incentive for platforms to prioritize safety by design and uphold a duty of care for younger users.”
- Long-term impacts on public trust
Extensive monitoring and data-gathering practices threaten public confidence in the management of digital affairs. Public-sector agencies that protect citizen data face increased scrutiny, potential reputational risks, and legal challenges under Australia’s privacy laws when they implement these measures.
Australia can enhance its dedication to protecting children by tackling these challenges with focused, privacy-aware strategies while prioritising privacy and cyber security as top priorities.
Prioritising privacy protection
Experts advocate for a deliberate transition towards measures that prioritise privacy and sustainability in response to the intricate relationship between online safety and data privacy. These solutions safeguard children’s rights, ensure accountability in the public sector, and enhance technological resilience.
- Strengthening the Duty of Care:
The Online Safety Act establishes a comprehensive duty of care framework that requires platforms to take responsibility for creating safe and age-appropriate spaces. Incorporating safety-by-design principles allows platforms to proactively reduce risks for young users while ensuring transparency and adherence to Australian privacy standards.
- Adopting a Children’s Online Privacy Code:
Children’s online interactions require a focused privacy framework that establishes clear guidelines for data collection, use, and storage. This code protects against excessive data collection and ensures that online resources remain accessible for various age groups. UNICEF emphasised that this action “ensures children’s data remains protected without compromising their ability to benefit from the digital environment.”
- Implementing Comprehensive Privacy Reforms:
Modernising Australia’s privacy laws is essential to aligning them with the best practices observed worldwide. Strengthening safeguards for children’s information involves restricting excessive data gathering and implementing stringent consequences for violations. This approach aligns with national cybersecurity objectives and fulfills international obligations under the UNCRC.
- Promoting Responsible Age-Verification Systems:
Privacy-focused age-verification technologies, including anonymised verification methods, can mitigate the dangers associated with widespread data collection. UNICEF raises alarms about the “population-wide age verification, as currently proposed, raises serious privacy concerns,” advocating instead for solutions that minimise data exposure while ensuring compliance.
- Fostering Public-Private Collaboration:
Successful outcomes rely on the collaboration of governmental entities, technological firms, and community organisations. A collaborative approach ensures that strategies remain feasible, implementable, and aligned with the diverse needs of children, families, and the public sector.
- Embedding Children’s Voices in Policy Design:
Engaging children in policymaking processes honours their rights as outlined by the UNCRC and helps develop more informed and effective legislation. UNICEF Australia emphasises that, “children’s perspectives must be central to the design of online safety measures, particularly those that directly impact their lives.”
These privacy-focused strategies safeguard the rights of children and enhance public confidence in Australia’s digital management, affirming the public sector’s role as a frontrunner in data privacy and online safety.
Securing digital public governance
The proposed Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Bill 2024 significantly impacts Australia’s public sector, particularly in areas of data privacy, cyber security, and digital governance. Public sector leaders manage the complexities of executing and supervising these initiatives while considering broader operational and ethical implications. The bill requires gathering and handling sensitive personal information for age verification.
This situation demands urgent attention to Australia’s privacy regulations, including the Privacy Act 1988, and increases the likelihood of regulatory scrutiny in cases of data breaches or improper use. Public agencies must implement cutting-edge cyber security measures to effectively address threats to citizen data. Storing extensive amounts of sensitive information, especially that of children, significantly raises the risk of cyberattacks.
Public-sector CIOs must implement strong encryption, maintain secure storage practices, and conduct regular audits to safeguard against breaches that could erode confidence in government-managed digital systems. Implementing and overseeing age-verification systems on a national level poses significant logistical challenges. Public-sector agencies collaborate effectively with technology providers and regulators to ensure systems operate efficiently, remain minimally intrusive, and cater to a wide range of user demographics in both urban and rural environments.
The Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Bill 2024 launches a crucial step in defining Australia’s digital landscape. Safeguarding children is admirable. However, it is essential to adjust the strategy meticulously to prevent any unforeseen repercussions. UNICEF Australia calls on policymakers to acknowledge that they can create a safer and more inclusive digital environment by implementing solutions that respect children’s rights, protect their privacy, and foster cooperation among all stakeholders.
By committing to transparency, innovation, and accountability, Australia’s public sector can set a benchmark for data governance worldwide—ensuring that Australia remains the safest environment for children to flourish online.